Your browser does not support JavaScript, You should enable JavaScript to use this website.
  • Main Menu
  • Specials

Main Menu

Kitchen Hours: Monday thru Friday 11 A.M.-2 P.M. and 5-9 P.M. Kitchen Closed on Monday Evening and Sunday. Open All Day Saturday! 11 a.M. - 8 P.M. Pub Hours: Monday thru Sunday 11 A.M. - 1 A.M

Appetizers

Appetizers Served w/ Your Choice of Dipping Sauce: Marinara Sauce, Southwestern Sauce, Sour Cream, BBQ Sauce, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Ranch or French Dressing

Nacho Chips

Served w/ Salsa and Sour Cream

W/ Salsa

5

W/ Chilli or Cheese

6

W/ Chilli and Cheese

6.5

Super Large Nachos

9.99

Toppings include Taco Meat, Cheese Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Black Olives and Jalapenos. Served w/ Salsa & Sour Cream

Mini Tacos

5

Bite-sized Tacos. Served w/ Salsa and Sour Cream

Haystack Beer-Battered Onion Rings

Served w/ Southwestern Sauce

1/2 Order

3.99

Whole Order

6.99

Breaded Mushrooms

6.99

w/ your choice of Dipping Sauce

Jalapeno Poppers

6.99

Deep-Fried Peppers stuffed w/ Cheddar Cheese

Mozzarella Sticks

6

Lightly seasoned, deep-fried & served w/ Marinara or your choice of dipping sauce

Mini Corn Dogs

6

Honey-flavor Battered and Bite-sized

Home-Made French Fries

Large Green Basket

4.5

Small Red Basket

2.5

Home-Made Chip

3

Baked Potato

2.5

Cheese Cubes

6.99

6-oz. Cheddar or Hot Pepper Jack Cheese

Deep-Fried Pickle Chips

6

Dill Pickles, breaded & fried golden brown

Sweet Potato Fries

5

Chili 'N Cheese Fries

6

Cheese Fries

5.5

Potato Skins

7.99

Baked to perfection! Filled w/ Bacon, Cheese and Sour Cream

Potato Skins w/ Chilli

8.99

Chicken Tenders

6.99

All White Meat Chicken

Buffalo Chicken Tenders

7.45

Featuring Carrigan's own Hot Sauce!

Cheese Quesadilla

6.99

Chicken Quesadilla

8.99

Deluxe Chicken Quesadilla

9.99

Onion, Jalapeno Pepper, Cheese & Mushrooms

Philly Steak Quesadilla

9.99

Green Pepper, Onion, Cheese & Mushrooms

Buffalo Wings or Plain

7.99

Hot and Spicy Wings served w/ Celery, Ranch or Blue Cheese. Made w/ Carrigan's own Hot Sauce! (Please allow additional 15 Minutes for cooking)

Irish Potato Skins (6)

9.99

Topped w/ Corned Beef, Kraut, Swiss Cheese & Thousand Island

Sampler Basket Special

Fill Your Own Basket

6.99

W/ Any 3 of the Following Appetizer Choices: Mozzarella Sticks, French Fries, Mini Tacos, Mini Corn Dogs or Breaded Mushrooms. And Your Choice of 2 Dipping Sauces

Butch's Pizza

Available Anytime

Sausage & Cheese

Deluxe, Garlic White or Cheese

7 Inch

5.99

9 Inch

7.99

12 Inch

9.99

Sandwiches

Sandwiches come with Home-Made Chips. Substitute Home-Made French Fries for $2. Add Extra Cheese $0.50, Mushrooms $0.75 or Bacon - $1 to Any Sandwich

Hot Dog

1.75

W/ Cheese

2.25

Chili Dog

2.25

W/ Cheese

2.75

2 Hot Tamales

6

W/ Chilli and Cheese

6.5

Grilled Cheese

On Texas Toast

4

W/ Bacon

5

House BLT

5.5

Mayo available

O'Carrigan's Home-Made Fresh Tenderloin

Served w/ your choice of Onion, Lettuce, Pickle and Tomato

1/2 Order

8.99

Whole Order

12.99

1 Pc Cod & Small Shrimp

7.99

w/ Fries

Philly Steak

8.99

Served w/ Hot Pepper or American Cheese, Grilled Onion & Pepper

Reuben

9.99

Corned Beef, Sauerkraut & Swiss Cheese and Thousand Island on Rye Bread

Grilled Pork Chop Sandwich

8.99

Served w/ BBQ Sauce

Turkey Club

7.99

Turkey, Bacon, American, Lettuce and Tomato on 3 Slices of Bread, served with a Pickle

Sub Sandwich

7.99

Turkey and Ham, Lettuce, American-Hot Pepper-or-Swiss Cheese, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle

Grilled Chicken Breast

7.99

7 oz. Chicken Breast w/ Onion, Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle. BBQ Sauce available

Buffalo Chicken Tender

7.99

w/ Onion, Tomato, Lettuce & Pickle

Buffalo Chicken Breast

8.99

7 oz. Grilled Chicken Breast w/ Onion, Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle

O'Joey Grilled Pub Chicken

8.99

w/ Bacon and Swiss Cheese

O'Warren Fish Sandwich

7.99

Available w/ Cheese and Tarter Sauce

O'Dan 1/2 Pub Burger

7.99

w/ Jalapenos, Bacon and Nacho Cheese

6 oz. Grilled Ribeye Steak Sandwich

9.99

w/ Grilled Onion and Pepper

1/4 Lb. Cheeseburger

W/ Chip

5.99

W/ Fries

6.99

1/2 Lb. Burger

W/ Onion, Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle

6.25

W/ American, Hot Peppers or Swiss Cheese

6.99

1/2 Lb. Pub Burger

7.99

w/ Bacon, Cheese, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle

Swiss Mushroom Burger

7.99

1/2 Lb. Hamburger w/ Swiss Cheese and Grilled Mushrooms

Bacon Blue Cheese Burger

7.99

1/2 Lb. Hamburger w/ Bacon and Blue Cheese Crumbles

Bacon Shredded Cheddar Burger

7.99

w/ Bacon, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato and Pickle

O'Jack Attack Pub Burger

8.99

Served w/ Bacon, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle. W/ Ghost Pepper Cheese or Chipotle Cheese

Western Pub Burger

7.99

1/2 Lb. Hamburger w/ Bacon, Straw Onion Rings and Sweet BBQ Sauce

Grilled Jalapeno Burger

7.99

1/2 Lb. Hamburger w/ Grilled Jalapeno and Hot Pepper Cheese

1/2 Lb. Pool Room Cole Slaw Burger

7.99

Cole Slaw and a Burger on a toasted bun. No other condiments recommended

O'Dave's Delight Burger

7.99

BBQ Sauce topped with a 1/2 Lb. Hamburger w/ Onion & Hot Pepper Cheese

1/2 Lb. Irish Burger

9.99

Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut w/ Thousand Island

Lucky Horseshoe

9.99

1/2 Lb. Hamburger, Corned Beef, or Philly Steak served on Toast w/ Fries piled on top and covered with Cheese Sauce. Chips not included

Salads

Dressing Choices: Ranch, Italian, Thousand Island, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Southwestern, Tomato Basil, French, Italian Olive Oil or Poppy Seed. Extra Dressing $0.50

Taco Salad

8.99

Shredded Lettuce, Taco Meat, Cheese, Tomato & Onion in a Tortilla Shell served with Jalapeno & Salsa, (Sour Cream or Ranch)

Chef Salad

8.99

Shredded Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Cheese, Tomato, Green Pepper, Onion and Egg

Chicken Breast Salad

8.99

Grilled, Diced Chicken with Shredded Lettuce, Cheese, Tomato, Onion and Green Pepper

Chicken Tender Salad

8.99

Fried Chicken Strips with Cheese, Tomato, Onion and Green Pepper

Buffalo Tender Salad

8.99

Shredded Lettuce with Sliced Breaded Chicken, Cheese, Tomato, Onion and Green Pepper

Side Salad

3.55

Shredded Lettuce with Cheese and Tomato

Cottage Cheese

2.55

Cole Slaw

2.55

Macaroni Salad

2.55

Beets

2.55

Apple Sauce

2.55

Potato Salad

2.55

Salad Bar

7.99

All-You-Can-Eat. Thursday thru Saturday

Soup and Chili!

Home-Made (in Season). Served with Crackers

Cup

4.5

Bowl

5.5

Drinks

16 oz. Soda or Tea

Pepsi

2

Diet Pepsi

2

Mt. Dew

2

Sierra Mist

2

Mug Root Beer

2

Dr. Pepper

2

Lipton Tea

2

Lipton Lemonade

2

Juice

Orange

2.5

Cranberry

2.5

Grapefruit

2.5

Beer

12 oz. Draft: Miller Lite, or Bud Light

1.5

16 oz. Draft: Shock Top, Guinness

4.5

16 oz. Draft: Michelob Ultra

2.5

16 oz. Draft: Amberbock

2.5

Bottles (Domestic)

3

Wine

By the Glass

Copper Ridge Chardonnay

5.5

White Zinfandel

5.5

Pink Rose

5.5

Cabernet

5.5

Merlot

5.5

Sangria

5.5

Drink Specials

Monday

Natty's Cans

1

Tuesday

Margarita or Corona Bottles

3

Wednesday

Domestic Bottles / Cans

2

Thursday

22 oz. Bud or Bud Light Bottles

4

24 oz. Miller Lite Bottles

4

Sunday

Bloody Mary

4

16 oz. Bud Light

2.5

Miller Lite Cans

2.5

Hot Dog

1

Chili Dog Bar

1

Kid's Menu

$5.99. Children Only Please. Served with French Fries & Applesauce

2 Pc. Chicken Tender

Hot Dog w/ Fries

5 Pc. Mini Corn Dogs

Grilled Cheese

Grilled Cheese w/ Bacon

Grilled PB & J

Mini Burger w/ Fries

Specials

Every Day Dinner Specials

The Following Dinner Specials include Baked Potato or French Fries, Vegetable, Salad and Dinner Roll

10 Pc. Large Fan Tail Shrimp

15.99

10 oz. Ribeye Steak

17.99

10 oz. Ribeye Steak & 5-Pc. Breaded Shrimp

19.99

Daily Specials

Monday Night Bar Only Special

6:00 - 8:00 P.M. Free Pool!

Butch's Pizza - All You Can Eat!

w/ 2 Drink Purchase

Tuesday Special

All Days!

Taco

Hard Shell

1.25

Soft Shell

1.5

Big Burrito

6.99

w/ Salsa & Sour Cream

Chili & Cheese Burrito

7.99

w/ Salsa & Sour Cream

Wednesday Special

All Days!

O' Carrigan's Home-Made Fresh Tenderloin

Served with Onion, Lettuce, Pickle and Tomato

Half

7.45

Whole

12.45

Thursday Special

Lunch Only!

All-You-Can Eat Pizza

6.5

Butch's Pizza w/ Salad

Country Fried Steak (Lunch or Dinner)

7.99

Served with Corn, Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

4-Pc. Chicken Dinner (5:00 - 9:00 P.M.)

10.99

Includes Mashed Potatoes or Fries, Vegetable, Salad Bar and Dinner Roll

Friday Specials

Cod & Shrimp Basket (Lunch Only!)

6.99

Served with French Fries and your choice of Shrimp or Tarter Sauce

16 oz. Catfish Dinner (5:00 - 9:00 P.M.)

15.99

Served with Baked Potato or French Fries, Vegetable, Salad Bar, Dinner roll, Corn Fritter or Apple Fritter

Walleye (5:00 - 9:00 P.M.)

11.99

2 Pieces served with Baked Potato or French Fries, Vegetable and Salad Bar

4-Pc. Chicken Dinner (5:00 - 9:00 P.M. - Friday & Saturday)

12.99

Includes Mashed Potatoes or Fries, Vegetable, Salad Bar and Dinner Roll